# The Strange, Clever, Slightly Unhinged History of the Cryptic Crossword
There was a time when the morning newspaper could ruin your entire day with seven words.
You would make the coffee.
Open the paper.
Read the headlines.
Turn to the crossword.
And discover something like:
Flower found in the bank? (5)
Then you would spend breakfast wondering whether the editor had made a terrible mistake.
He had not.
Welcome to the cryptic crossword.
For roughly a century, these peculiar little puzzles have been hiding instructions inside perfectly ordinary-looking sentences. They have survived radio, television, the internet, smartphones, social media, and countless predictions about the death of newspapers.
And somehow they are still here.
So where did this wonderfully unreasonable pastime come from?
Pour another cup of coffee. We are going back to the beginning.
The story starts before the crossword was cryptic at all.
On December 21, 1913, journalist Arthur Wynne published a diamond-shaped "word-cross" puzzle in the New York World.
It looked strange.
It had no black squares.
It was not even called a crossword yet.
But readers liked it.
Then they liked it a lot.
Other newspapers began printing their own versions, "word-cross" became "cross-word," the hyphen eventually wandered off, and a newspaper phenomenon was born.
By the 1920s, crossword fever had arrived.
There were crossword books. Crossword contests. Crossword dictionaries. People solved them on trains and at breakfast tables. Newspapers discovered that a grid full of little white squares could be remarkably good at keeping readers around.
But across the Atlantic, something was about to happen to the innocent crossword.
The British got hold of it.
And they began lying.
Fairly, of course.
His real name was Edward Powys Mathers.
But that was apparently not intimidating enough.
So he called himself Torquemada.
Yes, after the Spanish Grand Inquisitor.
Subtlety had not yet reached the crossword department.
In 1926, Mathers began setting puzzles for The Observer. His crossword ran there for more than 600 editions until his death in 1939.
And his clues were different.
Instead of simply asking for a synonym or piece of general knowledge, Torquemada began treating clues like miniature puzzles of their own.
Words could be rearranged.
Definitions could be disguised.
Instructions could be hidden inside ordinary English.
The sentence on the page said one thing.
The machinery underneath it said another.
The cryptic crossword was taking shape.
And Torquemada was not particularly interested in making life easy for anybody.
His puzzles developed a reputation for being ferociously difficult. He expected solvers to recognize literary references, unusual vocabulary, wordplay and whatever other traps he had decided to leave lying around that week.
His most infamous creation was not even a crossword.
In 1934 he published Cain's Jawbone, a 100-page murder mystery printed entirely out of order. Readers had to determine the correct order of the pages and identify the victims and murderers.
It was so difficult that only two solvers won the original competition.
Nearly a century later, people are still attempting it.
Torquemada apparently looked at the crossword and thought, "This is nice, but what if the entire book attacked you?"
By the late 1920s and 1930s, crosswords were becoming fixtures of British newspapers.
The Guardian, then the Manchester Guardian, published its first crossword in 1929.
Other papers developed their own traditions.
And something distinctly British began happening to the crossword clue.
It became less like a question and more like a contract between setter and solver.
The setter was allowed to deceive you.
The setter was encouraged to deceive you.
But somewhere inside the clue, everything you needed had to be there.
A word such as broken might mean that some letters need rearranging.
Reportedly might tell you to listen for a homophone.
Inside might signal a container.
Back might ask you to perform a reversal.
And a suspicious collection of letters might be sitting right under your nose as a hidden word.
This strange vocabulary of instructions grew into one of the defining features of cryptic solving.
Today we call those words indicators, and we have collected them in our Cryptic Crossword Indicator Dictionary.
Once you begin recognizing them, cryptic clues stop looking quite so much like acts of madness.
Usually.
Torquemada helped establish the form.
But another setter helped establish the rules.
Derrick Somerset Macnutt, a schoolmaster who set puzzles under the name Ximenes, succeeded Torquemada at The Observer in 1939.
If Torquemada was the wild inventor, Ximenes was the fellow who arrived afterward carrying a ruler.
Cryptic clues had become popular, but the question remained:
What makes one fair?
Ximenes became enormously influential in answering that question.
The emerging philosophy was simple even if the clues were not: a setter could misdirect the solver, but the wordplay had to work.
The definition had to work.
The grammar had to work.
The instructions had to be defensible.
A clue should make you groan because you missed something clever, not because the setter forgot to tell you something.
Another influential setter, Afrit, expressed the principle beautifully:
That idea sits at the heart of good cryptic clueing to this day.
The surface may tell a ridiculous little story.
Underneath it, the clue must keep its promises.
As setters refined the form, a collection of clue mechanisms became familiar.
An anagram scrambles letters.
A charade places pieces beside one another.
A hidden word conceals the answer inside the clue itself.
A double definition gives you two roads to the same answer.
A homophone relies on what something sounds like.
A reversal turns letters around.
A substitution sends one set of letters packing and brings another in.
And then there is the elegant little monster known as the &lit clue, where the whole clue somehow manages to function as both definition and wordplay.
These are not rigid boxes into which every clue must fit.
Setters combine them, bend them and disguise them.
But learn the basic mechanisms and suddenly the newspaper starts whispering its secrets.
If you're just beginning, our Cryptic Crossword Cheat Sheet keeps the major mechanisms and signals together in one place.
Keep it nearby.
Nobody from the crossword police is coming.
One of the loveliest traditions of British cryptics is that setters often publish under pseudonyms.
Torquemada.
Ximenes.
Azed.
Araucaria.
Enigmatist.
Paul.
The names became personalities hiding behind the grids.
Solvers learned their habits.
One setter might love puns. Another might reach for obscure vocabulary. Another might produce wonderfully smooth surfaces. Another might make you reconsider every decision that led you to purchasing that morning's newspaper.
A crossword was no longer merely a puzzle produced by a publication.
It was a weekly appointment with a particular mind.
That relationship between setter and solver remains one of the things that makes cryptics unusual.
You are not merely retrieving answers.
You are trying to figure out what another human being has done with language.
Every few decades, something arrives that is supposedly going to kill the crossword.
Radio did not.
Television did not.
Video games did not.
The internet did not.
Smartphones certainly did not.
In fact, digital publishing gave cryptics something newspapers never could: immediate checking, explanations, archives, communities and the ability to discover setters from around the world.
The grid escaped the printed page.
Then word games exploded all over again.
Sudoku became an international phenomenon.
Mobile puzzle apps appeared.
Wordle turned a five-letter guessing game into a morning ritual for millions.
And somewhere amid all of this, the cryptic crossword kept doing exactly what it had always done.
It placed a sentence in front of you and quietly dared you to read it differently.
There is a reason beginners sometimes look at a cryptic clue and conclude that everyone involved has lost their minds.
Nobody has told them the rules.
A standard crossword asks:
Do you know the answer?
A cryptic asks:
Can you discover how this sentence works?
That is a completely different skill.
Once you learn that a clue usually contains a definition and wordplay, things begin changing very quickly.
Then you learn indicators.
Then common abbreviations.
Then clue types.
Then one morning you see the word "reportedly" and immediately think HOMOPHONE.
Congratulations.
The transformation has begun.
Our Cryptic Crossword Glossary collects the strange terminology you'll encounter along the way, and our step-by-step guide to learning cryptic crosswords is designed for anyone currently staring at clues thinking, "I don't even know where to begin."
Begin there.
Not every cryptic is trying to destroy your afternoon.
Some clues are deliberately welcoming.
Others are designed for experienced solvers.
And some appear to have been constructed by somebody who holds a personal grudge against vowels.
Difficulty can come from several places: how visible the definition is, how clearly the indicator reveals itself, how complicated the wordplay becomes, how strong the misdirection is, and how accessible the eventual answer is.
At The Daily Cryptic, we measure those factors using our Cryptic Crossword Difficulty Scale.
The important distinction is that difficulty and unfairness are not the same thing.
A brutally difficult clue can still be perfectly fair.
In fact, the best hard clues usually are.
The moment the answer finally arrives, everything snaps into place.
Of course.
OF COURSE.
You briefly hate the setter.
Then you admire the setter.
Then you tell someone else the clue.
This is the natural lifecycle of a cryptic crossword.
Perhaps that is why the cryptic has lasted.
The technology surrounding it has changed enormously.
The basic pleasure has not.
Torquemada sat on one side of a newspaper page in the 1920s.
His readers sat on the other.
Between them was a tiny piece of language containing a secret.
Nearly a century later, we are still playing the same game.
A setter writes something that is true in two different ways.
A solver notices.
For a few seconds, two people who may never meet share exactly the same thought:
Oh, that's clever.
That is the real machinery underneath the cryptic crossword.
Not grids.
Not dictionaries.
Not abbreviations.
People.
One person hiding something.
Another person finding it.
The cryptic crossword began in newspapers, which is one reason we have such affection for that old world here at The Daily Cryptic.
Ink.
Columns.
Headlines.
Coffee beside the paper.
A puzzle waiting somewhere toward the back.
We may be reading on glowing screens now, but we do not see much reason to throw away the good parts.
So every day, we put one clue on the page.
No enormous grid required.
No hundred-year knowledge of crossword conventions required.
Just one little sentence.
Read it once.
Read it again.
Then become deeply suspicious of every word in it.
The old setters would be proud.
Or, more likely, they'd make a clue out of it.
A new daily cryptic clue every morning and the answer revealed every night, wherever you scroll.